You have options …
by Janet McCabe and Kim Akass — Manchester Metropolitan University
June 26, 2007 – 17:01
Way back in season five with the Sopranos’ marriage on the rocks, Carmela shops with Meadow. Tension breaks out in ladies fashions. Meadow berates her mother for having no thought beyond “being dependent on some man” while clutching clothes that Tony will pay for. The irony of her thinking may be lost on her, so firmly embedded is she in an economic world where everything is possible with a gold credit card paid for by daddy, but surely the paradox speaks to a broader debate raging in our culture about feminism. Few women are able to make the choices Meadow is advocating. As Alison Jaggar (1983) points out, liberal feminism may speak of individual freedom and female agency, but fails to comprehend the oppressions countenanced by others subject to different ethnic and class positionings. So what are the politics represented by Meadow and Carmela? Moreover, does not Meadow’s doublethink speak of being raised with feminist freedoms taking for granted options for women while rooted in an ideology organised around marriage and family? Licensed by liberal feminism does not Meadow fail to comprehend the intricacies of her mother’s situation, judging her harshly as a consequence? Is liberal feminism here functioning as a power policing women and their life choices (Bailey 2002: 138-54)? Meadow is an unlikely ‘feminist governor’ (150). Educated to know better (at Columbia, no less), and saturated in the privileged discourse of feminism lends clout to Meadow’s condemnation of the way her mother appears implicit in her own oppression. Is feminism emerging as a moralising force, shaping the ways in which Carmela’s choices are judged? Pitted against Meadow’s liberal feminist reasoning does not Carmela find herself on the wrong side of the intellectual divide? Or as Carmela puts it: “You have options, I have a lawyer.” Bibliography Cathryn Bailey, ‘Unpacking the Mother/Daughter Baggage: Reassessing Second- and Third-Wave Tensions,’ Women’s Studies Quarterly, 30: 3/4 (2002): 138-154 Alison Jaggar, Feminist Politics and Human Nature. Totowa, NJ: Rowman and Allanheld, 1983.
No one has reviewed this post… but you need to login to submit feedback
- What Do You Mean We Don't Have Goals?: Media Neglect of Occupy's Anti-Foreclosure Work
- I have an Army/We have a Hulk : Thinking Politics in The Avengers
- “‘Save Me Captain Stubing! Skeletor and The Lone Ranger have joined forces and are attacking the General Lee’: The place of play
- “Where Does a Girl Have to Go to Find a Pool Table: Gender Performance, Leisure, and The L Word in Second Life”
- Is secularism possible in the Arab region given the numerous influential factions that have a religious face?